Moonpointer : Buddhist Blog of Everyday Dharma




  • Ad

  • Slideshow

    Get the Flash Player to see the slideshow.
  • Stonepeace@Twitter

    • The most loving are the most lovely and lovable. 2012/04/26
    • The path of attaining Buddhahood is the path of perfecting wisdom 2 liberate oneself,and the path of perfecting compassion 2 liberate others 2012/03/21
    • [Pt2]The problem is not pleasure itself, as bliss from practising e Dharma is natural.The problem is clinging out of greed hatred amp; delusion 2012/03/21
    • [Pt 1] The problem is not desire itself, as aspiration 2 practise e Dharma is needed. The problem is craving out of greed, hatred amp; delusion 2012/03/21
    • When there is no need to judge, one should not judge with delusion. When there is need to judge, one should judge with wisdom. 2012/03/21
  • Subscribe Moonpointer Daily

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

  • Subscribe Moonpointer Weekly

  • AdLinks

  • Moonpointer Friends

  • Past Blogs







  • Links

    • Buddhist Channel
    • LivingVegan
    • Peta
    • Sea Shepherd
    • Sharkwater
    • TDE
    • VSS
  • Tags

    • 2012
    • acceptance
    • action
    • affinity
    • ageism
    • agnosticism
    • aloneness
    • Amitabha Buddha
    • Amituofo
    • analogy
    • Anatta
    • anger
    • Anicca
    • animal welfare
    • anxiety
    • apathy
    • appeal
    • appearance
    • appreciation
    • Arahat
    • Arhathood
    • arrogance
    • art
    • aspiration
    • astrology
    • asura
    • atheism
    • attachment
    • attitude
    • aversion
    • awareness
    • bad faith
    • beauty
    • belief
    • benevolence
    • birth
    • blame
    • blessing
    • blessings
    • bliss
    • Bodhicitta
    • Bodhidharma
    • Bodhisattva
    • Bodhisattvas
    • book
    • boredom
    • Buddha
    • Buddha-nature
    • Buddhahood
    • Buddhas
    • calmness
    • celebration
    • change
    • chanting
    • chaos
    • charity
    • choice
    • clarity
    • clinging
    • commitment
    • communication
    • compassion
    • complacence
    • complacency
    • complaint
    • concentration
    • confidence
    • conflict
    • conscience
    • consciousness
    • consumerism
    • contentment
    • courage
    • craving
    • criticism
    • cruelty
    • cult
    • curiosity
    • curse
    • death
    • deceit
    • dedication
    • defilements
    • delusion
    • demon
    • demonisation
    • demonisaton
    • demons
    • depression
    • design
    • desire
    • despair
    • destiny
    • determination
    • deva
    • devil
    • devotion
    • Dharma
    • Dharmakaya
    • Dharmapala
    • dignity
    • diligence
    • disappointment
    • discipline
    • discrimination
    • distraction
    • dogma
    • domestication
    • doubt
    • dream
    • duality
    • Dukkha
    • dying
    • effort
    • ego
    • Ehipassiko
    • emotion
    • empathy
    • emptiness
    • Energy
    • enlightenment
    • enmity
    • enthusiasm
    • Environmentalism
    • equanimity
    • eternalism
    • euthanasia
    • evil
    • evolution
    • existential crisis
    • existentialism
    • expectation
    • extinction
    • faith
    • fame
    • family
    • fantasy
    • fate
    • fear
    • feelings
    • fetter
    • filial piety
    • finance
    • fool
    • forgiveness
    • form
    • Four Noble Truths
    • freedom
    • free enquiry
    • friendship
    • funeral
    • gamble
    • game
    • generosity
    • ghost
    • ghosts
    • give blood
    • globalisation
    • God
    • gods
    • good
    • goodness
    • gratitude
    • greed
    • grief
    • grudge
    • Guanyin
    • guilt
    • guru
    • habit
    • haiku
    • happiness
    • harmony
    • hatred
    • healing
    • health
    • heaven
    • heavens
    • hell
    • honesty
    • honey
    • honour
    • hope
    • humanity
    • humility
    • humour
    • hungry ghost
    • ignorance
    • illness
    • illusion
    • imagination
    • impatience
    • impermanence
    • indignation
    • inspiration
    • instinct
    • integrity
    • intelligence
    • intention
    • interconnection
    • interde
    • interdependence
    • intoxication
    • intuition
    • invest
    • investment
    • irony
    • jealousy
    • joy
    • judgement
    • justice
    • Kalyanamitra
    • karma
    • killing
    • kindness
    • knowledge
    • koan
    • leadership
    • letting go
    • liberation
    • life
    • light
    • logic
    • loneliness
    • loss
    • love
    • loving-kindness
    • loyalty
    • lust
    • lying
    • machine
    • madness
    • Mahayana
    • management
    • mandala
    • mantra
    • Mara
    • marriage
    • materialism
    • matter
    • meaning
    • meaning of life
    • medicine
    • meditation
    • melancholy
    • memory
    • merits
    • Middle Path
    • Middle Way
    • milk
    • mind
    • mindfulness
    • miracle
    • moment
    • monastics
    • money
    • monster
    • morality
    • motivation
    • mudra
    • murder
    • mystery
    • myth
    • nihilism
    • Nirvana
    • Noble Eighfold Path
    • Noble Eightfold Path
    • nothing
    • now
    • objectivity
    • offering
    • offerings
    • Organic
    • organ transplant
    • pain
    • paradise
    • paradox
    • paramitas
    • parenthood
    • parinirvana
    • past lives
    • patience
    • peace
    • percception
    • perception
    • perfection
    • perfections
    • perseverance
    • pettiness
    • pilgrimage
    • politics
    • pollution
    • possibilities
    • power
    • practice
    • praise
    • prayer
    • prayers
    • precept
    • precepts
    • prejudice
    • pride
    • priority
    • probability
    • procrastination
    • prophecy
    • prophesy
    • punishment
    • Pureland
    • Pure Land
    • purity
    • purpose
    • quantum
    • rationalisation
    • reality
    • reason
    • rebirth
    • rebirths
    • recycling
    • reflection
    • refuge
    • regret
    • regrets
    • rejoice
    • relationship
    • relativity
    • relics
    • religions
    • renunciation
    • repentance
    • resistance
    • resolution
    • respect
    • responsibility
    • retreat
    • retribution
    • reverence
    • ritual
    • sacrifice
    • sadness
    • Samsara
    • Sangha
    • self
    • self-fulfilling prophesy
    • selfishness
    • selflessness
    • sensitivity
    • service
    • sex
    • sexuality
    • shame
    • shojin ryori
    • shrine
    • sickness
    • simplicity
    • sincerity
    • skilful means
    • sleep
    • smile
    • sorrow
    • speciesism
    • speech
    • spirituality
    • status
    • stealing
    • Stonepeace
    • Stream-winner
    • stress
    • stubbornness
    • student
    • stupa
    • stupidity
    • success
    • suffering
    • suicide
    • sun
    • Sunyata
    • superstition
    • Sutra
    • Sutta
    • TDE
    • teacher
    • teachers
    • technology
    • terrorism
    • The Dalai Lama
    • Theravada
    • Threefold Refuge
    • three poisons
    • time
    • tradition
    • tragedy
    • transience
    • translation
    • Triple Gem
    • True Happiness
    • True Love
    • trust
    • truth
    • truthfulness
    • twitter
    • understanding
    • universe
    • Vegetarianism & Veganism
    • vengeance
    • victory
    • violence
    • virtue
    • virtues
    • vow
    • war
    • wealth
    • wedding
    • will
    • wisdom
    • wit
    • work
    • worry
    • writing
    • Zen
    • zombie
« Debunking Pascal’s Wager | The Middle Way Today »

God’s Impossible Burden of Proof

By jianxie on 18 Oct 2011 under Odds & Ends | 2 Comments | Tags: God

The Self-Defeating God
(How God Proves He Does Not Exist By Not Proving He Does Exist)

Reasoning:

It is the primary existential responsibility of an almighty, good and wise creator,
if ‘he’ exists, to prove that ‘he’ exists to all ‘his’ creations beyond any doubt,
as ‘he’ is supposed to have all the might, goodness and wisdom needed to do so.

Observation:

Since ‘he’ cannot, does not and/or do not know how
to instantly convince ‘his’ creations that ‘he’ exists,
‘he’ is surely not an almighty, good and wise creator.

Hypothesis:

If ‘he’ exists, with valid reasons for being unable to convince all that ‘he’ exists,
it is still ‘his’ responsibility to readily convince all that ‘he’ has such valid reasons.
As he does not do so, ‘he’ is surely not an almighty, good and wise creator.

Conclusion:

As ‘he’ is not an almighty, good and wise creator,
there is no almighty, good and wise creator,
while ‘he’ must be a delusion created by ‘his’ self-appointed creations.

Note:

In the Buddhist perspective, though there is no one almighty, good and wise creator, there are gods with varying might, goodness and wisdom, some of whom thought they are creators. Note that though Buddhas are perfect in goodness and compassion, they are not creators, or they would not have created a flawless universe without suffering. They are also not almighty, or they would have removed suffering from the universe instantly. What is ‘almighty’ in Buddhism is the Dharma, the teachings realised and shared by the Buddhas, that lead to the end of all suffering, to the attainment of True Happiness when practised personally.

The above is inspired by ‘Russell’s Teapot’: 

‘Many orthodox people speak as though it were the business of sceptics to disprove received dogmas rather than of dogmatists to prove them. This is, of course, a mistake. If I were to suggest that between the Earth and Mars there is a china teapot revolving about the sun in an elliptical orbit, nobody would be able to disprove my assertion provided I were careful to add that the teapot is too small to be revealed even by our most powerful telescopes.

But if I were to go on to say that, since my assertion cannot be disproved, it is intolerable presumption on the part of human reason to doubt it, I should rightly be thought to be talking nonsense. If, however, the existence of such a teapot were affirmed in ancient books, taught as the sacred truth every Sunday, and instilled into the minds of children at school, hesitation to believe in its existence would become a mark of eccentricity and entitle the doubter to the attentions of the psychiatrist in an enlightened age or of the Inquisitor in an earlier time.’

- Bertrand Russell (Is There a God?)

God Works in Mysterious Ways?

An ad-hoc hypothesis thrown up by _____ when confronted with intractable contradiction in their absurd belief system. It is nothing more than a veiled confession of ignorance from someone who will say anything rather than question or confront their beliefs. When arguing with a believer, hearing this usually means you’ve won the debate.

“How can an all-loving God condemn so many people to eternal torment in hell?”
“Simple, God gave us a choice to either accept him or reject him.”
“But if God cares so much about us, then why does he need to coerce our devotion with the threat of torture? So why doesn’t God reveal himself and warn us about it? Why doesn’t he set the non-believers straight? Is our having faith so important to him that he’s willing to let millions of people be condemned?”
“Uh…God works in mysterious ways!”

http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=God%20works%20in%20mysterious%20ways

Delusional rationalisation works in amazing ways!
Not that ‘he’ exists, but if ‘he’ does,
don’t tell me that God works in mysterious ways
because it is his onus to demystify his own ways,
in order to prove that ‘he’ really exists.

‘Also, if there is a god, why did he make me an atheist?
That was his first mistake. Well, the talking snake was his first mistake.’

- Ricky Gervais

Share and Enjoy:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Google Buzz
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • LinkedIn
  • Print
  • email



Comments


2 Comments so far
    avatar  Atheius on October 20, 2011 16:36

    Why there is no creator god and god maybe atheist?
    Theist: There is a creator god
    Buddhist: There is no creator god but gods who all think they are the sole creator
    Theist: Mine is the real god and the rest are not. Why can’t you try to see it from a creationist pt of view?
    Buddhist: Ok. Here goes. If there is a creator god then there must be a creator of god.
    Theist: There is no creator of god. God is perfect and he cannot be created.
    Buddhist: There is a creator of god.
    Theist: There is no creator of god.
    Buddhist: Supposed we ask god personally if there is a creator of god and he says “no”….what does that make him? An atheist?

    avatar  Tinkerbelle on October 20, 2011 17:40

    If a perfect god doesn’t believe he can be created becos he is too perfect to be created. So do I for the reason that I am so imperfect that I can’t possibly be created by a perfect god. In conclusion. There is no creator god. Gods who think they are creators……yes.

    I am not a god but I can create and yes…happiness and suffering to other sentient beings and even to myself. In the same way, all beings are heirs to their own karmas they self created for themselves which impacts the fates and destinies of society, country, our world, the universe and beyond.

Name (required)

Email (required and will not be published)

Website (optional)

Do share your wisdom but please consider what you post, thank you!

CAPTCHA Image
Refresh
*

(B) (^) (P) (@) (O) (D) (C) (&) (E) (~) (K) (I) (L) (8) (T) (G) (U) (W) (F) (N) (Y) :-[ :-$ :-S ;-( :[[ (H) :-) (*) :-D :-P ;-) :bloody: :cool: :choler: :love: :oups: :aie: :beurk: :canny: :go: :88 :miam: :neo: :ueue: :nose: :oh: :-( :oups2: :prud: :aie3: :aie2: :creve: :bobo: :yo: :-O :dribble: :what: :kiss: :dream: :sweat: :sadd: :oo: :bloody2: 88) :cache: :rose: :loll: :pp :spd: :sure: :unsure: :yes: :pff: :hm: :-[)) :ciao: :gene: =(( ;)) ::(( :)) :DD :sb: :wink: :-|| :w00t: :angry: :blink: :blush: :cheerful: :cry: :dizzy: :ermm: :face: :getlost: :biggrin: :lol: :happy: :whistle: :kissing: :pinch: :sad: :shocked: :sick: :sideways: :silly: :smile: :tongue: :wassat: :ninjaa: :ninja: :pouty: :alien: :heart: :666: :devil: :bandit: :angel: :sleeping: :lovey: :wub:

  • Features

    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Album : India
    • Album : Borobudur
    • Album : Hong Kong
    • Album : Japan 1
    • Album : Japan 2
    • Album : Japan 3
    • How I Became Veg*n
    • Japan Tales
    • Movie Reviews With Buddhist Views
    • Zeph Stories
    • A Love History
    • Poll Archive
    • Moonpointer Wall
  • New Posts

    • The Hulk Paradox?
    • Forthrightness With Kindness
    • Guidance Needed
    • Soullessness
    • ‘Special’ Vegetarian Food?
    • Let’s End This Madness
    • Dharma Work
    • Gratitude Or Grudge
    • Being Assertive
    • Heavy Rain
    • Deliver Me
    • Honest Forthright Persons
    • Good & Evil-Knowing Advisors
    • About MaitriPals
    • Dharma Class Scheduling Koan
  • Recent Comments

    avatarDumbats on Let’s End This Madness
    avatarDumblebore on Let’s End This Madness
    avatarDreadcula on The Hulk Paradox?
    avatarAtomik on Soullessness
    avatarPeter Clothier on The Hulk Paradox?
    avatarNemo on Carnival Of Love?
    avatarIrene on Dharma Class Scheduling Koan
    avatarAtomik on Balanced View On Premarital Sex
    avatarAdamant on Balanced View On Premarital Sex
    avatardreamy on Carnival Of Love?
    avatarAnne on True Love (Stonepeace Saying)
    avatarken on This Golden Age
    avatarken on Advantages Of Dharma Discussions In Class
    avatarNemo on Are We In the Dharma-Ending Age?
    avatarken on Are We In the Dharma-Ending Age?
  • Food For Life

    Headquarters for the world's largest vegetarian food relief organization, serving up to one million freshly cooked vegetarian meals to the needy every day around the world.

  • Tweet

    • A BRAND NEW TDE Book 5 will be out soon! Stay tuned!

    • Share your views via commenting or write to us via Contact Us/Submit Article

    • You can still visit old Moonpointer by clicking here

  • Categories

    • Announcements (50)
    • Books (80)
    • Comics & Graphic Novels (110)
    • Current Affairs (39)
    • Designs (12)
    • Environmentalism (49)
    • Movies/TV (254)
    • Music (92)
    • Notices (3)
    • Odds & Ends (982)
    • Photojournal (144)
    • Poll (6)
    • Quotations (88)
    • Relationships (39)
    • TitTatTot (94)
    • Travelogue (52)
    • Vegetarianism & Veganism (194)
  • New Archives

    • May 2012 (23)
    • April 2012 (36)
    • March 2012 (24)
    • February 2012 (34)
    • January 2012 (61)
    • December 2011 (25)
    • November 2011 (49)
    • October 2011 (55)
    • September 2011 (61)
    • August 2011 (49)
    • July 2011 (57)
    • June 2011 (25)
    • May 2011 (36)
    • April 2011 (23)
    • March 2011 (39)
    • February 2011 (32)
    • January 2011 (47)
    • December 2010 (52)
    • November 2010 (66)
    • October 2010 (46)
    • September 2010 (52)
    • August 2010 (42)
    • July 2010 (65)
    • June 2010 (53)
    • May 2010 (85)
    • April 2010 (61)
    • March 2010 (66)
    • February 2010 (45)
    • January 2010 (56)
    • December 2009 (32)
    • November 2009 (56)
    • October 2009 (34)
    • September 2009 (55)
    • August 2009 (59)
    • July 2009 (55)
    • June 2009 (60)
    • May 2009 (29)
    • April 2009 (49)
    • March 2009 (59)
    • February 2009 (54)
    • January 2009 (53)
    • December 2008 (63)
    • November 2008 (18)
  • ADBooks

  • Moonpointer

  • Purelanders

  • More Links






  • Veggie Posters

  • RSS Buddhist Vegan Fellowship

    • Introducing Kyabje Chatral Rinpoche
    • Not A Laughing Matter
    • 狄葆贤语录 Quote by Di Baoxian
    • 愿云禅师《护生歌》
    • 弘一大师语录 Quote by Master Hongyi
  • RSS TDE

    • 11.05.12 : Mind One Needle | How Right Is Your Livelihood? | The Hol
    • 04.05.12 : Suffering Vs Blessings | Two Proven Pain-Free Solutions F
    • 26.04.12 : Sutra Practice | With Every Breath You Take | The Four No
    • 13.04.12 : Born From Karma | Universal Past, Present & Future Key To
    • Get TheDailyEnlightenment Book 5 Now :-]
  • RSS Buddhist Channel

    • Buddhist monks filmed smoking, drinking, playing poker
    • Buddhist monks who strayed
    • South Korea Buddhist leaders resign over gambling scandal
    • Nepal’s kung fu nuns practise karma with a kick
    • China 'trained female devotees to poison Dalai Lama'
Avatars by Sterling Adventures




Creative Commons License This site is protected by WP-CopyRightPro